diff --git a/SECURITY.md b/SECURITY.md index 0f01769..cdde0b0 100644 --- a/SECURITY.md +++ b/SECURITY.md @@ -126,3 +126,66 @@ reported 212 HIGH/CRITICAL package findings, including FFmpeg 7.1.5 and curl inventory and SPDX SBOM in `agent-image-evidence-ARM64-1`. This is **not** a security-clean image or permission to ship it; resolving these native-library findings without dropping required capture/codecs remains a rollout blocker. + +### Supported-base alternative investigation (2026-10-26) + +Compared the current **Debian 13 Trixie** runtime against **Debian 12.15 +Bookworm LTS**, using the [Debian security tracker JSON](https://security-tracker.debian.org/tracker/data/json) +and the exact 44 distinct HIGH/CRITICAL CVEs from the native image report. +[Bookworm remains supported until 2028-06-30](https://www.debian.org/releases/bookworm/) +on its listed LTS architectures. Its current FFmpeg is +`7:5.1.9-0+deb12u1`, curl is `7.88.1-10+deb12u15`, and libxml2 is +`2.9.14+dfsg-1.3~deb12u6`. + +This supported alternative does **not** clear the gate: **42 of the 44 CVEs +remain open**, including the critical libxml2 `CVE-2026-6653`, both curl CVEs, +and 15 of the 16 FFmpeg CVEs. Bookworm is marked unaffected (`fixed_version=0`) +for FFmpeg `CVE-2026-66041` and libxml2 `CVE-2026-86139`; that improvement is +not sufficient to release. + +Bookworm is also not a drop-in runtime replacement: this CGO binary is linked +to FFmpeg 7's `libavcodec.so.61`/`libavutil.so.59`, while Bookworm's FFmpeg 5 +uses different SONAMEs (`libavcodec.so.59`/`libavutil.so.57`). Both the Go/native +builder and runtime would require a matched rebuild and codec/device regression +validation. No Bookworm image was built or claimed compatible after the +security metadata already demonstrated the unresolved blockers. Bookworm LTS +also no longer covers armel; it is not a silent solution for the retained ARMv6 +requirement. + +The tracker reports FFmpeg fixes in `7:9.0.2-1`, curl fixes in +`8.21.0~rc2-1`/`8.21.0~rc3-1`, and the critical libxml2 fix in +`2.14.5+dfsg-0.1` in **Forky**. However, +[Forky is testing, without timely Security Team support](https://www.debian.org/releases/forky/), +not a supported stable-base upgrade; cjson, libsndfile, libX11 and libXrender +blockers also remain open there. It was not substituted into production. +Dropping unused administration tools alone cannot resolve the required FFmpeg +decoder/parser findings. No codec, device integration, remote terminal or +ARMv6 target was removed to obtain a clean scan. + +The required decision is whether to wait for supported-distribution fixes or +approve an explicitly maintained native-package/backport source or supported +media image, with ownership for security updates and validation across the +retained architectures. Such a change needs fresh matching native inventory, +image scans and camera/codec/device tests; it is not authorization to ignore +these findings or switch to an unsupported testing distribution. + +#### Exact blocking native CVEs + +These are the source components behind the 212 package findings in Debian 13.7; +several FFmpeg binaries/libraries share the same source advisories: + +| Source component | CVEs | +| --- | --- | +| util-linux | CVE-2026-76642, CVE-2026-78408, CVE-2026-78409, CVE-2026-78410 | +| curl | CVE-2026-12064, CVE-2026-8458 | +| ffmpeg | CVE-2026-58049, CVE-2026-64830, CVE-2026-64832, CVE-2026-64833, CVE-2026-64834, CVE-2026-64835, CVE-2026-66036, CVE-2026-66039, CVE-2026-66040, CVE-2026-66041, CVE-2026-70628, CVE-2026-70632, CVE-2026-75142, CVE-2026-75143, CVE-2026-75144, CVE-2026-75146 | +| acl | CVE-2026-54369 | +| cjson | CVE-2026-16554, CVE-2026-29036, CVE-2026-67215, CVE-2026-67216, CVE-2026-87933 | +| ncurses | CVE-2025-69720 | +| libsndfile | CVE-2026-37555 | +| systemd | CVE-2026-16742 | +| tiff | CVE-2026-36849, CVE-2026-52490 | +| libX11 | CVE-2026-88806 | +| libxml2 | CVE-2026-6653 (CRITICAL), CVE-2026-74860, CVE-2026-86138, CVE-2026-86139, CVE-2026-86140, CVE-2026-86142, CVE-2026-86143, CVE-2026-86144 | +| libXrender | CVE-2026-88807 | +| perl | CVE-2026-9538 |